Keith
Natalie is high school royalty, but her queen bee status falls apart when she falls for the new guy at school. Although Keith ignores her at first, they soon become friends -- even though Natalie suspects that Keith has something to hide. As the free-spirited Keith shows Natalie how to embrace what life offers, they grow closer -- until a secret tests the bounds of their relationship
Elisabeth Harnois
Natalie
Jesse McCartney
Keith
Ignacio Serricchio
Raff
Margo Harshman
Brooke
Michael McGrady
Pete
Jennifer Grey
Caroline
Michael O'Keefe
Alan Ascher
Ethan Phillips
Mr. Miles
Eric Parker
Travis
Jessy Schram
Courtney
Micah Henson
Shane
Ian Nelson
Brian
Tabitha Brownstone
Cynthia
Sam Murphy
Zach
Sarah Zinsser
Office Lady
Ron Carlson
English Teacher
Megan Hubbell
Officious Girl
Courtney Halverson
Junior Girl
Janice Kent
Woman
Zack Rockefeller
Billy
Jan Devereaux
Secretary
Rachel Thorp
Girl
Tim Halligan
Father
Michael Bryan French
Principal Sassen
Gareth Williams
Henry
Lee Turner
Joe
Jesse Heiman
Chemistry Class Student (uncredited)
Victoria Chalaya
Lea (uncredited)
Dennis Cockrum
Assistant Principal (uncredited)
Rance Howard
Old Man (uncredited)